Қазақстан шығыстануы, 2026, т. 18, № 2
AN ANALYSIS OF SARAICHIK IN THE WESTERN EUROPEAN HISTORIOGRAPHY OF THE ULUS OF JOCHI
Аннотация · Abstract
The aim of this article is to demonstrate how the city of Saraichik has been represented in Western European historiography from the nineteenth to the twenty first century on the basis of both classical synthetic works and modern studies on the Jochid Ulus and post Horde polities. The relevance of the research stems from the fact that Saraichik is frequently mentioned in scholarly and popular literature as an important hub of Golden Horde communications and as a sacred funerary center. In Western scholarship, however, such views have often been constructed on the basis of a limited body of information, toponymic confusion, and secondary compilations, which makes critical clarification and revision necessary. The novelty of the study lies in the systematic overview of Western interpretations of Saraichik with an emphasis on recurring narrative motifs and source dependencies. The methodology is grounded in source critical and comparative historiographical analysis and includes the identification of repeated errors and borrowings. The results show that Western authors most often describe Saraichik within three frameworks. It is presented as a transit node within the Horde road network, as a space of memory and funerary sacralization of the elite, and as a key point within the Nogai political landscape of the late medieval period. The most problematic cases involve the conflation of Sarai, Lower Sarai, and Saraichik and the uncritical use of compilative information. The article concludes that the idea of Saraichik as a sacred funerary site is generally plausible. However, personal attributions and chronological claims in Western scholarship often remain hypothetical and require further verification through renewed critical reading of the sources.
Сведения · Details
- DOI 10.63051/kos.2026.2.241
- Журнал · Journal Қазақстан шығыстануы
- Язык · Language английский
- Цитирования (Crossref) · Citations 0