Central AsianResearch Index

Telemedicine as an Effective Tool for Ensuring Access to Healthcare: A Comparative Legal Analysis of the Experiences of Ukraine and the Republic of Kazakhstan

Телемедицина як ефективний інструмент доступності медичної допомоги: Порівняльно-правовий аналіз досвіду України та Республіки Казахстан

Introduction. Remote care cannot always account for latent data in the medical history, the patient’s somatic condition, and the course of the disease, which may subsequently lead to negative consequences for the patient’s health. However, the legal standard of care in telemedicine remains identical to that of an in-person consultation. Objective. To conduct a comparative legal analysis of telemedicine regulation in Ukraine and the Republic of Kazakhstan in order to identify best practices in both countries and, if necessary, adopt best practices for implementation in each state. Methods. Among general scientific methods, the dialectical, structural-functional, comparative, and generalization methods were primarily applied. In the course of the study, the following specialized legal methods were used, in particular: the method of legal interpretation and the formal-legal method. Results. The regulatory framework for telemedicine in Ukraine and Kazakhstan has been analyzed, specifically highlighting: 1) in Ukraine, two terms are established: “telemedicine” and “telerehabilitation,” the latter of which is a method of telemedicine. It is emphasized that it would be more appropriate either to separate telerehabilitation, just as rehabilitation is separated from medical care, or to retain only telemedicine as a tool for providing medical and/or rehabilitation care; 2) the subject composition of legal relations concerning the provision of medical and/or rehabilitation care using telemedicine was examined, and it was noted that Kazakhstan has a broader range of participants involved in medical legal relationships using telemedicine, due to the inclusion of a social worker and the patient’s legal representative. In addition, it is noted that the range of rehabilitation specialists as parties to these legal relationships is significant, and such Ukrainian experience may be of interest to the Republic of Kazakhstan, given that remote services also extend to the provision of medical rehabilitation services. Conclusion. The legal framework for organizing remote services in Kazakhstan is similar in substance to Ukraine’s, though it sometimes differs in the level of detail and clarity of the provisions. Ukraine’s European integration trajectory clearly expands the country’s telemedicine capabilities and facilitates access to medical care for patients beyond the borders of a single state, as evidenced by the draft law “On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine Regarding the Implementation of European Law in the Field of Cross-Border Provision of Medical Services and Coordination of Social Security Systems in the Part Concerning Medical Services”. Keywords: telemedicine, telerehabilitation, medical care, remote medical services, patient safety.

Сведения

Опубликовано
2026 · Т. 126, № 3, С. amj016
Язык
Английский
ISSN
1562-2940 · 2790-1203
Издатель
NpJSC "Astana Medical University
Аффилиации
DNT “Danylo Halytsky Lviv National Medical University”