Central AsianResearch Index

TRANSNATIONAL DIALOGUE OF COURTS AND RECEPTION LEGAL STANDARDS OF THE EURASIAN ECONOMIC UNION AND THE "ASTANA" INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL CENTER IN THE LEGAL SYSTEM OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN

This article examines the mechanisms and limits of the reception of legal standards of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) and the Astana International Financial Centre (AIFC) into the national legal system of the Republic of Kazakhstan, analysed through the lens of transnational judicial dialogue theory. Kazakhstan constitutes a unique «legal laboratory» in which three distinct legal frameworks operate simultaneously: the civil law tradition underpinning national legislation, the common law framework of the AIFC based on the principles of the law of England and Wales, and the supranational law of the EAEU. The methodological basis of the study comprises a combination of approaches: comparative law, formal legal analysis, historical and systemic methods, as well as case study analysis. The empirical foundation draws upon the Treaty on the EAEU of 29 May 2014, the Constitutional Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan «On the Astana International Financial Centre» of 7 December 2015, advisory opinions of the EAEU Court, judgments of the AIFC Court, and the case law of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan in customs and competition matters. Through the analysis of specific judicial cases, the article identifies three forms of transnational judicial interaction within Kazakhstan's legal landscape: horizontal dialogue between the AIFC Court and national courts, vertical dialogue between the Supreme Court of Kazakhstan and the EAEU Court, and a mixed form of interaction arising where the standards of both regimes intersect. The study finds that the classical hierarchical model of legal sources, as enshrined in Article 4 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan, is no longer adequate to describe the existing multi-layered legal reality. As an alternative, the article advances the original concept of «network sovereignty», within which judicial dialogue serves as an indispensable instrument for harmonising competing legal orders. On the basis of the analysis conducted, the article puts forward practical legislative recommendations aimed at improving the institutional mechanisms governing interaction between the diverse legal regimes operating within Kazakhstan.

Сведения

Опубликовано
2026 · Т. 1, № 426, С. 386-397
Язык
Английский
ISSN
1994-408X · 2788-5283 · 2788-5291
Издатель
Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan