Central AsianResearch Index

FEATURES OF EVALUATING DIGITAL EVIDENCE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS

Digital technologies are rapidly transforming not only the form of evidence, but also the very logic of its presentation in criminal proceedings. The need to adapt law enforcement practices to new conditions, in which evidence is often intangible and technically complex, is becoming increasingly important. At the same time, courts generally lack sufficient expertise in the field of digital technology, and current legislation does not contain clear procedures for evaluating such data. The article emphasizes the relevance of developing a universal standard for the admissibility of digital evidence based on international approaches. The author justifies the need to institutionalize digital forensics as an integral part of effective investigation and judicial review of cases, emphasizing the role of professional training of specialists and the mandatory involvement of technical experts when working with digital evidence. He analyzes the legal and technical aspects of presenting digital evidence in court, such as authenticity, reproducibility, integrity, and procedural admissibility. The study is based on current legislation, judicial practice, international standards, and expert opinions. The article draws well-founded conclusions that the absence of specific provisions in the Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan complicates the legal classification of digital materials and creates a risk of judicial errors. It is proposed to introduce methodological recommendations for judges, create a list of acceptable digital tools, and establish mandatory technical verification of data. A comparative overview of the practice of the European Court of Human Rights and the standards of the Council of Europe is provided. This work is intended for lawyers, investigators, prosecutors, and experts dealing with digital evidence, and may also be useful in the development of future criminal procedure reform in the field of digital technology.

Сведения

Опубликовано
2026 · № 417, С. 391-399
Язык
Английский
ISSN
1994-408X · 2788-5283 · 2788-5291
Издатель
Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan