Central AsianResearch Index

DEVELOPING A CONCEPTUAL APPROACH TO THE CLASSIFICATION OF LABOR DISPUTES: DELIMITATION CRITERIA AND LEGAL CONSEQUENCES

The article is devoted to developing a conceptual approach to the classification of labor disputes. The purpose of the study is to substantiate a conceptual approach to the classification of labor disputes based on delimitation criteria that have not only theoretical, but also direct procedural and legal significance. The methodological framework of the study comprises a set of general scientific and special legal methods, including the dialectical, formal-legal, formal-logical, and comparative legal methods. The empirical basis includes the regulatory legal acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the explanations of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan, materials of the International Labour Organization, as well as scholarly sources by Kazakhstani and foreign authors devoted to distinguishing disputes of rights from disputes of interests. The study establishes that traditional classification models (primarily based on the subject-based criterion) do not ensure the required “procedural precision” and may lead to conflation of disputes of different legal nature, which reduces the predictability of outcomes and contributes to inconsistent practice. It is substantiated that an appropriate classification should be linked to procedural consequences, including the choice of a dispute settlement mechanism, the limits of judicial review, evidentiary specifics, and the legal forms of protection. As a result, a three-part classification of labor disputes is proposed: (1) disputes of interests (concerning the establishment of new or changes to existing working conditions), (2) disputes of rights (concerning the application of labor legislation and the performance of established obligations, including collective agreements and social partnership agreements), and (3) disputes on declaring a collective agreement or a social partnership agreement invalid in whole or in part. It is shown that the proposed delimitation is consistent with foreign doctrinal approaches and has practical potential for unifying law enforcement and improving procedures for resolving labor conflicts in Kazakhstan. The findings of the study may be used in research activities, the educational process, as well as in preparing proposals for the development of labor legislation and the interpretative practice of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan.

Сведения

Опубликовано
2026 · Т. 1, № 417, С. 148-160
Язык
Английский
ISSN
1994-408X · 2788-5283 · 2788-5291
Издатель
Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan