Human Body As Legal Phenomenon
The following research is devoted to the reasoning of the body as a legal phenomenon. After all, despite the fact that the body is ontologically the closest thing to us, from the legal point of view it is one of the most mysterious legal phenomena. In other words traditional jurisprudence usually divides all legal beings into subjects of law (the state, individuals and legal entities, the nation etc.) and objects of legal relations (estate, material evidence, objects of dispute, etc.). However the body cannot be identified within these criteria. On the one hand the body itself is not a subject of law. After all, purely disembodied, abstract entities, such as legal entities or the state, are subjects of law, sometimes without any material "embodiment". On the other hand purely corporeal existence does not guarantee legal personality, since, for example, the presence of a dead body as such indicates its absence. The similar conditions are fully reflected in the national legislation of Ukraine. Its analysis shows that the human body is not defined as an independent object of legal regulation and there is no corresponding legal regime. The most symptomatic manifestation of the total disregard for the legal issues of the body is the absence of a corresponding term even in special medical legislation regulating organ transplantation, health care and medical assistance. Therefore the phenomenon of the body currently remains outside the attention of lawyers. This leads to the lack of a conceptual reasoning of the body as a legal phenomenon and uncertainty of legal regulation of the human body as such. So it is worth to conclude that the phenomenon of the body needs to be comprehended from a philosophical and legal point of view. The result of such comprehension is the identification of the following ontological features of the body as a legal phenomenon: syncretism, liminality and intentionality of the body. This, in turn, creates certain grounds to assert that normativity is immanently present in the body, when the body itself is a hypothesis and disposition for others, and the impossibility of communication with it is a sanction. As a result the author concludes that the inviolability of the body should be enshrined in law and the relevant amendments should be made to the Civil and Criminal Codes of Ukraine.
Сведения
- Журнал
- Law and State
- Опубликовано
- 2024 · Т. 104, № 3
- Язык
- Английский
- ISSN
- 2307-5201 · 2307-521X
- Издатель
- Maqsut Narikbayev University (Eurasian Frontier Publications)