Central AsianResearch Index

EPISTEMOLOGY OF NONCONCEPTUAL RECOGNITION IN MAHĀYĀNA BUDDHISM AND TENGRIANISM: A PHENOMENOLOGICAL ANALYSIS

ЭПИСТЕМОЛОГИЯ НЕКОНЦЕПТУАЛЬНОГО УЗНАВАНИЯ В БУДДИЗМЕ МАХАЯНЫ И ТЕНГРИАНСТВЕ: ФЕНОМЕНОЛОГИЧЕСКИЙ АНАЛИЗ

This article presents a phenomenological investigation of nonconceptual modes of perceiving the sacred in the context of the cultural encounter between Mahāyāna Buddhism and the Tengrian tradition of Central Asia. Unlike approaches focused on comparative analysis of doctrines or terminological correspondences, the author proposes an original methodology based on a synthesis of Western phenomenology (Husserl, Merleau-Ponty, Varela), Buddhist epistemology (Mādhyamaka, Yogācāra, Prajñāpāramitā), and the philosophical concepts of contemporary Central Asian thinkers (Ayazbekova, Alymbaev, Abaev). The study emphasizes the phenomena of bodily and ritual experience emerging in the space between traditions – such as silence, the body, ritual, sound, emptiness, and sky – and introduces the authorial concept of “multiple spirituality”, denoting the coexistence of diverse modes of nonconceptual recognition of the sacred, which are not reducible to a single doctrine but manifest through embodied presence, attention, and co-presence with the world. Śūnyatā in Buddhism and Tengri as a non-objective height in Tengrianism are interpreted as parallel forms of openness that resist conceptual fixation. The article’s form is intentionally chosen as a phenomenological practice: rather than a linear argumentation, the reader is offered a structure, rhythm, and contemplative stance that engages them with the investigated space. The phenomenological analysis of sacred elements – emptiness, suchness, steppe ritual, attention, and silence – reveals the possibility of an epistemology of recognition, in which knowledge is not a representation of the world but a form of co-presence with it. In conclusion, the article does not offer a traditional summary but invites attentive silence as the authentic ground for philosophical reflection.

Сведения

Опубликовано
2026 · Т. 26, № 2, С. 88-94
Язык
Английский
ISSN
1694-500X · 1694-6839
Издатель
State Educational Institution of Higher Vocational Education Kyrgyz-Russian Slavic University