Central AsianResearch Index

Влияние корректности заполнения медицинских свидетельств о смерти на статистику здравоохранения

The quality of official mortality statistics is directly dependent on the accuracy of medical death certificates. If these documents do not follow the logical sequence of causes of death (immediate cause, intermediate conditions, underlying cause) or if only the mechanisms of death are recorded instead of diseases, the picture of causes of mortality in society is distorted. This can lead to incorrect prioritisation in healthcare, inefficient allocation of resources and reduced effectiveness of epidemiological surveillance. What is the problem? Medical death certificates are key documents that contain information about the cause of a person's death and their main demographic characteristics. Official mortality statistics are compiled on the basis of data from the ICD, which play an important role in health system planning, evaluating its effectiveness, and in government and scientific management. However, problems often arise when completing the ICD, which negatively affect the quality and reliability of statistical data: - incomplete or inaccurate information about the cause of death. The MSS must indicate the entire chain of conditions that led to death: from the immediate cause through intermediate diseases to the underlying cause. But often, medical workers limit themselves to describing symptoms (e.g., ‘cardiac arrest’) or do not record the intermediate stages of the disease. This reduces the informative value of statistical data on causes of death; - Insufficient qualifications of medical workers and experts and the lack of uniform methodological materials. Many medical workers do not have sufficient knowledge to correctly fill out the medical death certificates and select the underlying cause of death in accordance with the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10). This leads to significant distortions in mortality statistics. - coding errors and inconsistencies in filling out forms. Common problems include mixing up the underlying and contributing diagnoses, incorrect use of sections of the form (parts I and II), confusion with the classification of external and internal causes of death, errors in indicating the violent nature of death, etc. Such shortcomings make it difficult to combine data and compare it between regions and time periods; - problems with data quality when a patient has multiple diseases. When a person is diagnosed with several clinically significant pathologies, healthcare professionals often indicate only one of the diseases or choose the most obvious one, ignoring the rest. This leads to an incomplete reflection of cause-and-effect relationships and a distortion of the mortality structure, especially in the case of chronic diseases, where it is important to take into account the interaction of various pathologies. Taken together, these problems seriously distort mortality statistics, make it difficult to assess the prevalence and severity of various diseases, and undermine confidence in the healthcare system. All this hinders the effective planning of preventive and therapeutic measures. The analysis revealed a number of systemic problems: gaps in the training of medical workers, shortcomings in the methodological support of their activities, weak quality control, and problems with coordination between different departments. Policy options The following approaches could be considered to improve the situation: - including ICD-related issues in educational programmes for healthcare professionals; - introducing mandatory continuing education and certification for healthcare professionals and experts; - conducting regular audits of the quality of ICD data entry; - developing an interdepartmental programme to improve the quality of mortality data. Vision for implementing policy options The proposed measures are not a set of isolated actions, but a comprehensive strategy to improve the quality of ICD completion and the reliability of mortality data. The first aspect of the strategy is education and training. Including topics related to the medical death certificates and ICD-10 in curricula will help reduce the likelihood of errors among young professionals. Regular certification and professional development courses for doctors, experts and employees of related organisations will help maintain uniform standards of work and readiness for changes in legislation and international practices. The second aspect is auditing and interdepartmental cooperation. Regular monitoring of the quality of MSS completion and provision of feedback will enable typical errors to be identified and eliminated promptly. A national interagency programme will help coordinate the efforts of health care, forensic medical services and statistical agencies, minimise data distortion and strengthen confidence in official statistics both domestically and internationally.

Сведения

Опубликовано
2025 · С. jhd029
Язык
Русский
ISSN
2663-1768 · 2663-1776 · 2225-9929
Издатель
Salidat Kairbekova National Research Center for Health Development