Central AsianResearch Index

The Müller–Breslau passive earth pressure coefficient: validity domain, degeneracy and quantification of the planar failure-surface error

The Müller–Breslau closed-form solution for the passive earth pressure coefficient Kp(φ, α, β, δ) remains the standard design tool for cohesionless backfill, yet it overestimates passive resistance severely at high wall friction, and its domain — including the degeneracy at which Kp grows unbounded — has never been mapped systematically. This study maps the domain over φ = 20–50° and quantifies the planar failure-surface error in a unified computational framework. Direct numerical minimization of the Coulomb trial wedge under the admissibility conditions β < ρ < ρsing reproduces the closed form to machine precision over a dense four-parameter grid of φ, α, β and δ (45 948 combinations at which the closed form is defined), so that its difference from Sokolovski's method of characteristics measures the planar failure-surface error alone. The divergence of the closed form is shown analytically to occur exactly on the locus φ + δ + β − α = 90°, at which the singular direction ρsing reaches the backfill surface and the admissible fan of trial planes closes; beyond this locus the formula yields no prediction, although the exact resistance stays finite. The error lies consistently on the unsafe side (99.6% of cells) and is governed primarily by the margin ε = 90° − (φ + δ + β − α) to the degeneracy locus: the median overestimation grows from about 2% for ε > 50° to more than 50% for ε < 20°, reaching a factor of 1.5–5 at δ = φ, as verified independently by a rotational log-spiral upper bound, a static lower-bound solution and rigorous finite-element limit-analysis bracketing over a 330-case matrix (92.4% of cases enclosed within a ±1% tolerance, including the region beyond the locus), and anchored to the Kérisel–Absi tables over the entire rough-wall range. The results are condensed into applicability maps with safe, caution, significant-error and degenerate zones for direct design use.

Сведения

Опубликовано
2026 · Т. 156, № 3, С. 19-41
Язык
Турецкий
ISSN
3136-3377 · 3136-3385
Издатель
L. N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University