Central Asian Research Index

Eurasian Journal of History, 2025, т. 119, № 3, с. 262-269

Linguistic and semantic problems in the philosophy of translation

Z.S. Iskakova, A.B. Aitbayeva, N.A. Muminov, A.A. Ryskiyeva

Аннотация · Abstract

The philosophy of translation faces several linguistic and semantic problems related to the transfer of meaning between different languages. One of the key tasks of translation is to ensure equivalence, that is, to preserve the meaning of the original when using the means of another language. However, this is not always possible due to differences in vocabulary, grammar, and cultural contexts. The study’s purpose is to identify and analyze the main difficulties associated with the transfer of meaning between different languages, with an emphasis on the philosophical aspects of equivalence and untranslatability. The methodology includes a comparative analysis of linguistic structures and semantic fields, and a review of philosophical approaches to translation. Some researchers believe that some linguistic elements cannot be adequately translated into another language due to the uniqueness of cultural and semantic contexts. This applies, for example, to idioms, metaphors, and specific terms deeply ingrained ina particular culture. In such cases, the translator faces a choice: use tracing paper, adapt the expression, or resort to explanatory translation. The possibility of fully conveying the original text’s meaning in another language is the subject of philosophical debate. Some philosophers believe that since each language represents a unique worldview, translation inevitably entails the loss or change of meaning. Others argue that despite the differences, it is possible to achieve functional equivalence, in which the translation causes the reader to have similar reactions and understanding as the original. Therefore, translation is not just a technical process of replacing words from one language with words from another, but a deep philosophical and linguisticaction that requires considering many factors to preserve and accurately convey meaning. The study identified key factors affecting the accuracy and adequacy of translation, such as cultural context, semantic features of languages and their grammatical structures. The research results can be applied both in theoretical translation studies and the practical translation of philosophical and artistic texts. The conclusions emphasize the need to consider cultural and semantic nuances to achieve equivalence andadequacy in translation.

Сведения · Details