Central AsianResearch Index

Framing Human Security in Development: A Critical Discourse Analysis of World Bank Projects in the Aral Sea Basin Spatiotemporal Distribution Analysis of Rainfall in the Harirud-Murghab River Basin, Afghanistan

The Aral Sea crisis, a landmark case of human-induced environmental disaster, has prompted extensive international intervention. The World Bank (WB), as a major donor, plays a pivotal role in shaping responses to this crisis. This paper argues that the WB’s interventions are legitimized through a powerful discursive strategy: the partial securitization of the crisis as a threat to human security. Using Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) and securitization theory, this study examines how the WB frames the Aral Sea’s degradation in two key projects: the Syr Darya Control and Northern Aral Sea Phase I Project (NAS) and the Climate Adaptation and Mitigation Program for the Aral Sea Basin (CAMP4ASB). The analysis reveals that by constructing a narrative of imminent threat, the WB prioritizes technical, top-down solutions and measurable economic outcomes. This WB’s strategy in the Aral Sea basin, however, effectively depoliticizes the crisis, obscuring its historical and socio-political roots and sidelining community participation and structural inequities. This paper identifies a process of partial securitization, whereby the WB frames an issue as a critical threat to human security to justify intervention, but deliberately contains it within the realm of technical, market-based solutions, thereby avoiding the full political ramifications of a traditional securitization “speech act”. The study concludes by discussing the implications of this security framing for development policy and advocates for more inclusive, locally grounded approaches to environmental governance.

Сведения

Опубликовано
2026 · Т. 12, № 1, С. 36-67
Язык
Английский
ISSN
2522-9060
Издатель
Kazakh-German University
Аффилиации
GEDT, University of Geneva
“Shaping Policy and Law” and “Building Peace Through Water Diplomacy” programmes, Geneva Water Hub
Institute of Migrations, Comillas Pontifical University
Faculty of Social Sciences, Charles University